Save on House

From Data to Your Dream Home

Winnipeg Real Estate – Home Prices, Sales History & Market Trends

House

586 Carlaw Avenue

BasementYes, renovated
PoolNo
GarageNone
Building TypeTwo Storey

Map

Redder color means more recent sale.

Yellow star means multiple sale records.

Neighbourhood sales statistics

Lord Roberts

How to read: Share of sales in each ~$50k price band for “lord roberts” (Detached houses (non-condo), 2024). The tallest band is the mainstream budget range; multi-year view shows how that band shifts over time.

Data summary (Winnipeg / lord roberts / Detached houses (non-condo) / 2024): ~$50k bands. The largest share is $250K–$300K (about 30.9%). Second-largest band: $300K–$350K (about 21.3%); top two together about 52.1%. About 94 sales in this view (sample size check).

All figures above are based on real sold transaction data analysis; for source details, see

Rankings

Living Area

1,160 sqft

Same street

16/80
Top 20%
Avg1,057 sqft

Same area

542/1828
Top 30%
Avg1,071 sqft

City-wide

104675/194458
Top 54%
Avg1,342 sqft

586 Carlaw Avenue: Living Area Analysis

  • Street Level (Carlaw Avenue): Above Average. Ranked #16 out of 80 (Top 20%). The average living area for comparable homes on this street is 1,057 sqft.
  • Neighborhood Level (Lord Roberts): Above Average. Ranked #542 out of 1,828 (Top 30%). The neighborhood average for this group is 1,071 sqft.
  • Citywide Level (Winnipeg): Around Average. Ranked #104,675 out of 194,458 (Top 54%). The citywide average for comparable homes is 1,342 sqft.

Assessed Value

250k

Same street

35/80
Top 44%
Avg282.5k

Same area

1079/1828
Top 59%
Avg286.7k

City-wide

161091/194458
Top 83%
Avg390.1k

586 Carlaw Avenue: Assessed Value Analysis

  • Street Level (Carlaw Avenue): Around Average. Ranked #35 out of 80 (Top 44%). The average assessed value for comparable homes on this street is 282.5k.
  • Neighborhood Level (Lord Roberts): Around Average. Ranked #1,079 out of 1,828 (Top 59%). The neighborhood average for this group is 286.7k.
  • Citywide Level (Winnipeg): Below Average. Ranked #161,091 out of 194,458 (Top 83%). The citywide average for comparable homes is 390.1k.

Year Built

1977

Same street

13/80
Top 16%
Avg1941

Same area

133/1828
Top 7%
Avg1933

City-wide

72028/194458
Top 37%
Avg1966

586 Carlaw Avenue: Year Built Analysis

  • Street Level (Carlaw Avenue): Above Average. Ranked #13 out of 80 (Top 16%). The average year built for comparable homes on this street is 1941.
  • Neighborhood Level (Lord Roberts): Above Average. Ranked #133 out of 1,828 (Top 7%). The neighborhood average for this group is 1933.
  • Citywide Level (Winnipeg): Around Average. Ranked #72,028 out of 194,458 (Top 37%). The citywide average for comparable homes is 1966.

Land Area

2,498 sqft

Same street

60/80
Top 75%
Avg2,944 sqft

Same area

1343/1828
Top 73%
Avg3,482 sqft

City-wide

186436/194458
Top 96%
Avg6,570 sqft

586 Carlaw Avenue: Land Area Analysis

  • Street Level (Carlaw Avenue): Below Average. Ranked #60 out of 80 (Top 75%). The average land area for comparable homes on this street is 2,944 sqft.
  • Neighborhood Level (Lord Roberts): Below Average. Ranked #1,343 out of 1,828 (Top 73%). The neighborhood average for this group is 3,482 sqft.
  • Citywide Level (Winnipeg): Below Average. Ranked #186,436 out of 194,458 (Top 96%). The citywide average for comparable homes is 6,570 sqft.

To see this property on a map next to nearby houses—and compare year built, living area, assessed value, and lot size in detail—open the neighbourhood analysis page.

Sales History

Sold 7/2024CA$200k–250k
Sold price

Same street

Top 67%

Same area

Top 63%

City-wide

Top 81%

586 Carlaw Avenue · Sold transaction data notes

Data source:

Sold prices are based on publicly available internet data. We do not guarantee accuracy; figures have had limited verification and are reasonably reliable. Data is not sourced from the MLS and does not involve MLS copyright.

Coverage:

Sold price data from January 2016 through April 2025; some months may be missing.

Precision:

If you are not signed in, we show sold price ranges in CA$50k bands, not exact amounts. To see exact sold prices, please create an account and sign in.

How do I get fully verified figures?

Because of industry association rules, this system does not include MLS sold records and does not display them on the site. If you need a property’s full transaction history and exact figures, email us. We will look them up manually and send them by email. You can email us or leave your email below (if you are already logged in, we have your email—click the button to request). We will send exact sold prices by email. Manual lookup and sending may take until the end of the same day at the latest. No tricks—we will not use your email for ads or spam.

Request exact figures by email

People interested in 586 Carlaw Avenue often also view these related homes

Highlights & common questions: 586 Carlaw Avenue, Winnipeg

Property Overview

This home at 586 Carlaw Avenue in Winnipeg's Lord Roberts neighbourhood presents a practical and efficient living proposition. Its key appeal lies in offering above-average interior space for its immediate area and price point, housed within a relatively modern structure for the community.

Key Characteristics & Suitability

The 1,160 sqft home, built in 1977, is notably newer than most in Lord Roberts, potentially offering advantages in layout and systems over the neighbourhood's many century-old homes. While the lot size is modest for the city, it is fairly typical for the area and translates to lower maintenance. The assessed value sits comfortably in the middle range for the street and neighbourhood, but is well below the Winnipeg city average, suggesting a value-oriented entry point into a central community.

This property would suit first-time buyers or downsizers seeking a manageable, move-in-ready home without the upkeep challenges of a much older property. It’s also a pragmatic choice for value-focused buyers who prioritize living space over land size, and who appreciate being in an established neighbourhood without paying a premium for a historic character home.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What does the "above average" ranking for living area actually mean?
It means that, compared to 80 homes on Carlaw Avenue, this house's interior space (1,160 sqft) is larger than about 80% of them. It offers more room than is typical for the immediate street.

2. The lot is ranked "below average" for the city. Is that a major concern?
For city-wide comparisons, yes—lots in newer suburbs are much larger. However, within the Lord Roberts neighbourhood, the lot is only slightly below the local average. This is characteristic of central, established areas and results in less yard work.

3. The home was built in 1977. What are the implications of that era?
Homes from this period often feature more open floor plans than pre-war houses and may have modern electrical systems. Buyers should have standard inspections for components like the roof, windows, and original heating system, which are at an age where updates are common.

4. Why is the city-wide assessed value ranking so low (Top 83%)?
This indicates the home's $250k assessment is significantly lower than the Winnipeg average (closer to $390k). This isn't a negative reflection on the property itself, but rather shows it is priced within a more affordable segment of the market, typical of its neighbourhood.

5. How reliable are the sold price ranges shown?
The ranges are based on public data. For the exact sold price history—crucial for making an informed offer—you need to request the detailed report via email, as the provider manually verifies and supplies this information.

Nearby & similar assessment

Map & Street View